Skip to content
VaultLab
Journal
Download free
Book spines lit warmly from one side, the titles legible on the nearest few and falling into shadow behind.

Marginalia

I write in books. Pencil, always, and lightly, which I tell myself is a courtesy to whoever gets them next and is really about being able to change my mind.

The notes are not insights. Nobody's are. Mine are mostly a vertical line down the margin meaning this bit, an occasional no, and once every forty or fifty pages something closer to a sentence. Rereading them years later is a strange experience, because the vertical lines are almost always in the right place and the sentences are almost always embarrassing.

The line in the margin is the honest note. It records that something landed, without the pressure of explaining why, which is a pressure I usually fail.

The best book I own is a second-hand copy of an essay collection with somebody else's pencil in it. They were reading it in about 1985, at a guess, from the handwriting and from one date in the back. They disagreed with the author far more than I do, and they were often right, and in one place they have written half a page of rebuttal in the space at the end of a chapter and then crossed it out. Not scribbled out. A single neat line through each sentence, so it all remains readable.

I have thought about that crossing out more than anything in the book itself. A person argued with a writer, in private, in pencil, and then decided to let the argument stand and be visibly withdrawn at the same time. Forty years later a stranger is reading both halves of that decision.

That is what the pencil is for.

Style